The Trouble is Assuming Racists Care — The “Better Black” Myth

Originally posted on Huffington Post 

There is a certain wave of race (and the corollary of racialism/racism) denialism that ebbs and flows in some spaces. It has many names. It is a language of present-day “colourblindness” and muted sighs of “rainbowism” coupled with “Sometimes, it’s not about race, but about class.” These varying views, however seemingly divergent (at least on the surface), have one thing in common: They assume that racists care.

The terrible truth, however, is that racist don’t care.

Racism, by its very definition, is not rational. If it exists in a system and space that inadvertently promotes (even rewards) irrationality, even worse. For the United States, we see this in the manifestly asinine way in which people like Donald Trump and Ted Cruz, like marauding evangelists, air their views on race. In Southern Africa, where a thin veil of Kumbayaness occasionally covers up reality, the irrationality of racism is best exemplified by white-owned business shunning black customers. One would assume that the economics of numbers would rid racists of this irrationality, but it doesn’t.
2016-04-05-1459848274-2975826-ScreenShot20160405at11.22.24AM.png 2016-04-05-1459848293-5851542-ScreenShot20160405at11.23.00AM.png

So why assume that classism and racism are not chummy bedfellows?

Having accepted the irrationality of racism, it becomes somewhat ironic that there are black people who have taken charge of the racism denialism movement. For the most part these are middle income self-professed “upwardly mobile” black folk. Having gotten access into spaces previously reserved only for non-black people, they (not “we,” for while I am a middle income self-professed “upwardly mobile” black woman, I do not pretend that racism no longer exists) now triumphantly assert that, “It’s not about race, it’s really just about class now.” They are now part of the petty (not petit) bourgeoisie, so they should know, right? The riding assumption being that “race” and “class” are entirely removed from each other in the minds of racists. But if the birther movement that attempted to divest Barack Obama of his Americanness (and thus – more ironies – his whiteness) is anything to go by, you can be the richest, shiniest, smartest black person and racists will still seek to remind you that you are inferior. You aren’t. But they’ll try.

So, dear Middle income self-professed “upwardly mobile” black folk who do not experience overt racism regularly (it is a question of frequency, really) or whose circle of friends resemble a Michael Jackson music video: just because you can afford to insulate yourselves (sometimes), does not mean racism does not exist. You are not “better blacks” who “transcend race.”

Your ability to “speak so well,” “work hard,” and “not stand out,” does not mean that your blackness is invisible (or blurry at best). It isn’t.

Racists don’t care.

Racists will find a way to “explain” how – black as you are – you are where you are. Your belief that your “class” means you are transracial doesn’t concern them.

Racists don’t really care how you fuel your car, pay your rent and feed your pangs. The irrationality that buttresses racism will problematise your income and the social class you think it affords you. Racism will problematise you.

To find a strange kind of comfort in being the “exceptional black people” whose income has ensured themselves a place outside “racism,” is to deny a certain uncomfortable reality: Race and class are inextricably linked – even for the upwardly mobile whatwhats.

The trouble in assuming that racists make distinctions between the black people they can tolerate and those they won’t is that you position yourself as the “better black” with a better chance of being liked.

The trouble is assuming that racists care and that they would rationally parse blackness for your convenience.

But of course, if you clutch your credit-bought pearls hard enough, you can make it just about class…

5 thoughts on “The Trouble is Assuming Racists Care — The “Better Black” Myth

  1. I’m constantly asked, “How come I speak English so well?”. I used to not understand why that mattered, but subconsciously it fed my middle class, better black superior self-perception. In truth the irrational nature of racism goes a step further when you see that we believe it too and see our race as inferior. Education and class haven’t really changed that. I love your post -‘Racists don’t care’. Its true we should not measure our success by how many white people live in the same neighborhood as us.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Came across this and couldn’t help but comment. Such truth here and I’m here for that. I liked this post but especially loved the last bit about “credit bought pearls”


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s